I had a student once whose first name was Usa. It was not actually her real first name, but, being from Samoa whose alphabet has only 7 consonants and all the vowels that requires that every vowel in any word is pronounced, the name her parents gave her was quite the thing to have to say without a lot of practice before hand and trial runs when pronouncing it by anyone, such as myself, who was a novice when it came to the Samoan language. She, like the other Samoan kids in the school, who followed this same practice of using an easier name over their birth name first because they knew their real names were very difficult for the novice to stumble through and to be more “American” knew that chosen because of her father’s military connection and love of his new homeland, was much easier to pronounce than her relatively short name, Pepeulelei.
Taking attendance on the first day of school involved a tortured attempt to respectfully pronounce the Samoan names, and after many attempts with accompanying apologies, the kids would let you know what they had chosen as their American name.
This was common in other school districts in which I worked where Asian and Latinx kids would prefer an English name either to be more American, or to avoid a name that had a beautiful meaning in their native language but in English was not at all good. Kids being named after the concept of tolerance in Vietnamese were quick to learn the English meaning was not a compliment.
For Kindergarten to high school graduation, their official name only appeared on official documents while in common practice they were known and called by their chosen name by all students and employees at their schools, and no on had a problem with that.
In the age of Facebook, a student who may not have been in the teacher’s class but, perhaps, had gotten involved in an extra curriculum activity supervised by the teacher may seem unknown to the teacher when they make a friend request until, when checking the “About” section of their Facebook page, the teacher sees the only known familiar name in parentheses after the real first name.
I have been surprised thus many times when, years after no longer being at the school and the student having long graduated such a request is made and, even if not intending to accept the request, I check out the About page to see if I remember the ki9d.
I also had English students who realized the name given at birth did not play well over time and wanted a name with less baggage or undertones of the past, old names like Patience, Chastity, and Badfish, that were their parents’ pean to important historical locals were abandoned in favor of more up to date names. If you did not have a student in class and so did not see their official name on anything, you called the students by the name they were known by.
He might have been Pablo on the role sheet, but he was Paul everywhere else.
This is why it amazes me that conservatives and evangelicals object to using a student’s chosen name and are passing laws to forbid this.
The Arkansas legislature is working on a law that would allow educators to misgender and deadname students if they wish, and for whatever their motivation might be, and protect them from reprimands if they choose to do so.
Misgendering is treating the student according to inaccurate information on their birth certificates.
Deadnaming is insisting on calling a Transgender student by the erroneous name given at birth as opposed the chosen name adopted when the student began acting and presenting themselves as the person they actually are.
House Bill 1749 passed the Arkansas House and is now in the state senate’s Education Committee is named “An Act To Prohibit Requiring Public School And Institution Of Higher Education Employees From Addressing A Student By A Term That Identifies A Student As Male Or Female And That Is Inconsistent With The Student’s Biological Sex,”
and employees of a public school or a state-supported higher education institution
“shall not be required to use pronoun, title, or other word to identify a public school student” if the employee believes to do so “is inconsistent with the public school student’s biological sex.”
I learned early on in my teaching career to address students by generic, non- gender specific titles like “Doctor”, “Professor”, and “you there”. This helped if I forget a name, couldn’t pronounce it, or wasn’t sure because a student’s manner of dress did not make gender identification easy.
This bill does not explain how an educator would determine a student’s assumed biological sex, so the bill’s sponsor claimed they could amend the bill to clarify later if they find it necessary. In other words, there is nothing happening that calls for this law, but they will look for a rationale later, after the law is passed.
Members of the state’s House Education Committee have admitted that concerns about reprisals for deadnaming or misgendering a student weren’t something they’d heard from teachers, and one Republican legislator has admitted that the number of teachers that had been sued for not using a student’s preferred name or pronoun in Arkansas stands at zero.
State lawmakers justify this law as protection of teachers, indemnifying them from lawsuits if they choose not to respect a student’s identity.
As a teacher of 38 years, I would not respect a teacher who is so petty as to do that for their own political, personal, or religious biases, nor would anyone who sees the stupidity of some teacher who would be that mean. There are some I have encountered that had such a mean streak.
Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson, a Republican, had vetoed a recently passed law that banned gender-affirming healthcare to minors because he believed such health concerns should be addressed by doctors not politicians.
He considers this denial of healthcare “unnecessary” and has requested the state’s Department of Education to do further evaluating.
His veto was overridden.
The law about allowing the use of misgendering and dead-names is the state’s fourth anti-Transgender legislation that either has been or is on its way to be encoded in law this calendar year Are you suffering from erectile dysfunction? Do you feel exhausted than usual? Well, you are check stock ordine cialis on line not alone to suffer from this problem. People should take these issues into consideration as a serious problem and should go for an urgent cure for it. cialis pills effects of When it comes to erectile dysfunction people suffering from erectile dsyfunction have the following common complaints Cannot achieve a complete erection by excitement of mind and pfizer viagra 100mg even by stimulation with hand. The organ does cheap cialis not become erect until the shaft of the organ gets filled with blood. alone.
The Bill’s sponsor justifies it as its
“not compelling anyone’s speech. It’s not prohibiting anyone’s speech. It’s helping those professors and teachers in our schools that do not want to be sued for not using a certain person’s pronoun.”
Don’t want to be sued? Respect the kid and don’t be the street name for a male’s genitalia. Call the student by the preferred name. It won’t kill anyone.
His name was “Jesse” or “Yeshua” but Christians not only call him by the name Jesus, they then gave Him, a Jew, a Greek surname.
While comparing Trangender and Gender Non-conforming students to people that identify as animals and claiming it is already “a real issue” the Bill’s sponsor claimed,
“This bill is just a first step to help protect our teachers but when we have students in school now that don’t identify as a boy or a girl but as a cat, as a furry, we have issues.”
A Furry is someone who identifies as human with an interest in anthropomorphized animals. Think Micky Mouse. Furries range from simply being fans of TV shows and video games featuring anthropomorphic animals, dressing as their favorite characters, think of the fans at Comic-con dressing as their favorite anime characters without claiming to actually be them, people who develop a highly specific furry character (“fursona”), to those who are “otherkin seeing themselves as not fully human on a spiritual or mental level.
Like all other groups, regardless what those who choose impression over fact want to have us all believe, Furries are not monolithic.
According to Dr. Courtney Plante, a social psychologist at the University of Waterloo and member of the Anthropomorphic Research Project team, Furries are equal to other fan groups, like comic book enthusiasts or Trekkers, with comic books about characters who are like animals, or artwork with humans with animal traits being forms of Furry artwork.
Furries do not claim to be the animals they dress as since they identify as a person, not as cats or any other animal.
So far this year Anti-Transgender legislation proposed and/or enacted in the state of Arkansas includes the one that was vetoed but overridden, the aforementioned so-called “Arkansas Save Adolescents From Experimentation (SAFE) Act”,
a Bill banning Transgender youth from participating in sports,
a Bill expanding religious exemptions, yet again, for health care workers, allowing doctors, nurses, EMTs, and other workers to refuse care for people if they cite their “religious, moral or ethical” beliefs as the reason to deny routine healthcare or emergency assistance to GLBT people,
and
a Bill that would allow government entities to be sued for permitting a person to use a restroom designated for a sex different from the sex a person was assigned at birth.
Considering that you can fit more urinals in a restroom than you can toilet stalls, that men use toilets less than urinals so there are more of them, and that the number of restrooms in government buildings are equal in number for both sexes, that the difference between the number of urinals vs the number of stalls a restroom holds forces on women more and subtle limits to relieving themselves than men, often resulting in the common practice for a woman to slip into a less crowded and even empty men’s room to use a toilet.
Ladies, consider the temptation to use the lineless men’s room rather than wait for the long line into the Ladies’ room at wedding receptions. If this were to happen at a conference or for any reason in a government building, your decision would give some “morality cop” the opportunity to sue that entity because you desperately needed to pee.
Even Walmart has a problem with all these anti-Transgender moves with Tom Walton, Sam’s grandson, stating in a post on the Walmart website,
“This trend is harmful and sends the wrong message to those willing to invest in or visit our state. We support Gov. Asa Hutchinson’s recent veto of discriminatory policy and implore government, business and community leaders to consider the impact of existing and future policy that limits basic freedoms and does not promote inclusiveness in our communities and economy.”
A school employee who is so disrespectful of students by refusing to call them by their name chosen to match their deep-seated self-identity or their preferred pronouns while calling other students by their commonly used name is targeted discrimination and is an abuse of authority and just a mean-spirited exercise of negative power over students.
A classroom’s effectiveness and the chance for student achievement depend on the rapport between teacher and student, but this, this is a rapport destroyer which not only influences the student’s physical wellbeing, but, when added to all the other anti-Transgender laws, the student’s mental health.
It is plain and simple.
The way these bills allow and encourage adults to negatively treat students is legally sanctioned, politically motivated child abuse.,
,
,
